How close is Cristiano Ronaldo to either Maradona or Pele?
Por dmitri

One number nine shirt danced the stepover at the Bernabeu, and then scored from the spot. Post-match interview showed a different Cristiano. Ronaldo didn’t mature in England; he is about to in Spain. If reports on his ambitions are true, which is to become the best player ever, there are two role models for him to follow.

 

Manchester days saw a Cristiano full of himself, with hints of Diego Maradona’s brash character. Opposite of him stood the steady Lionel. A humble Messi (Iniesta too) is more of the Pele type. Putting things to place, Cristiano and Lionel haven’t accomplished enough to compare with the likes of Xavi Hernandez, whose quality and achievements at par with Gullit or Platini. Now, die hard CR fans dont worry. Putting optimism to things, Ronaldo, Messi plus few others substantially have room for growth to reach even bigger things than those other names; but how?


Considering Maradona’s path, Ronaldo doesn’t have the flair or creativity. Winning copa mundial for Portugal, though, will excuse all flaws, and I would argue that Portugal today is a more talented side than Argentina in 1986.

 

Pele’s path also demands world cup sacrifice and other personal records. But Pele wasn’t a player who drags a team on two feet and a handfist. He was the niceguy superstar who completed a world class side: the icing on a cake. Ronaldo could also be that icing on a team backboned by Xabi Alonso and Kaka, whose superpass could take advantage of Ronaldo’s pace. But to become someone like Pele, Ronaldo must change his attitude. Perhaps Kaka could assist in a newborn Cristiano.

 

Which path do you think suits Cristiano most, and how do you fancy his chances?

28  Comentários
Por  lazio365
06.09.2009 00:58
Ronaldo is still young, so their is plenty of time for him to carve out his own path in many respects. However, football in todays world is celebrity obsessed and it becomes hard for any player for that matter to maintain high performance levels for say 10-15 years. Ronaldinho is somewhat proof of this, and it was only a few years ago he was suggested as heir to the throne as it were. Taking this into consideration, will anyone ever match the career and achievements of Pele? Everyone remembers Pele from that magical 1970 side, but lets not forget he was wonderful well before that. 1958, and 1962 for that matter where he made some fantastic contributions towards Brazil winning those world cups. Maradona is a different kettle of fish, but left an impact on the sport that may never be surpased. Moments of pure genius and pure destruction make his career notes absorbing reading. Ronaldo ultimately has a long way to go for me to even be mentioned in the same breath as Maradona and Pele, and other players, Van Basten, Cruyff and as you mention Platini. Congrats on a thought provoking blog.
Por  Mani18
06.09.2009 11:23
Ronaldo at best will make it into the top 11 of all time, but will not be able to get into the ever young Pele-Maradonna debate. One of the problems is that he is not a play maker and not a real striker. Ronaldo is very dangerous, but he needs space so he comes from the right. Maradona was the master on the field.
Por  CCCPPlus
06.09.2009 15:26
thanks for the comments, lads. @Mani: that makes Messi a likelier candidate. are there any wingers you know of who could operate without much space? what abt Garrincha or Jairzinho, Giggs or .... Litbarski? :)
Por  Mani18
06.09.2009 16:45
@Dmitri: fair point, but these players are never had a shot on being considered the best in the world.
Por  ruxspin
06.09.2009 21:58
Ronaldo has achieved very little when compared to the great players and far to young to be in the hall of fame just a flash in the pan guaranteed to blow it due to his vile mentality and attitude Madrid should suit him .
07.09.2009 06:43
Ronaldo is a good player ..that's it...But counting him among the best in the world is stretching it a bit too far...Additionally Soccer is a team game...Players like Messi, Xavi, Gerrard not only are tremendous individual contributors ..but also has a rare gift of raising the team as a cohesive unit... which apparently the likes of Ronaldo, Drogba apparent;ly lacks.
07.09.2009 10:43
When he wins a World Cup-i might give it some thought but after seeing his display for Portugal against Denmark-No WAY JOSE-lol-Great Goal from Nikki Bendtner-lol
07.09.2009 10:58
no ways...its like comparing gutter water with drinking water ..its too fictional to even think of.............
Por  Mani18
07.09.2009 16:41
@Neal: Looks like he will not even make it to this world cup
Por  urubu
07.09.2009 19:31
Cristiano Ronaldo is far from a hundred big football stars. Put Eusebio in place of Maradona / Pele and this issue will make some sense.
Por  CCCPPlus
07.09.2009 19:48
@Everyone: hahaha... no one offers Ronaldo a path to follow LOL. his future is bleak. what do Real supporters say about this? -- @Mani: yes, you're right @Neal: Bendtner is good for a player who doesnt do stepovers. valuable @michael: i heard recently Benitez criticised Gerrard. Rafa correct in that instance?
08.09.2009 06:56
Dmitri..I will answer your question with another question....Who is more Liverpool ? Gerrard or Benitez ? Stevie G has been pulling this team for a long time and will continue to do so for a while to come...
Por  sam_flame
08.09.2009 08:31
@mani... wat about alfredo di stefano? hes an all time gr8. he never played in a world cup...
08.09.2009 09:09
Messi is better at a Younger Age and has Won More and He is Midget-lol
Por  sam_flame
08.09.2009 18:02
messi cant carry a team... ronnie can...
Por  ruxspin
09.09.2009 01:07
Only a plane ride away ! Dmitri most Espaniapool fans were so brainwashed or supportive they and SKY reporters accepted this debateable point which in my opinion was very rich considering he sold Alonso!!!!!
Por  CCCPPlus
09.09.2009 11:11
@Micahel: really like your answer. put me in my place :)) @Teddy: good point. i was wondering abt Alonso too while writing this blog. most responses agree that CR nowhere near either Pele/Maradona. now, will the likes of Alonso (or Kaka, Raul) influence CR for the better?
Por  bih_girl
10.09.2009 02:32
not so close...he's individual player who plays for his name and fame...i don't like that type of player even Ronaldo is gr8 one but not brave one:P
10.09.2009 06:36
yup i totally agree with MICAHEL nd ELMA ............ronaldo was never a team player......
Por  sam_flame
10.09.2009 08:29
that is ronaldos undoing... the fact tht he's no team player would(and should) make him a poorer player... the thing is, like many greats, ronaldo has the ability to carry his club and his national squad, single handedly. he can win( or even lose) matches all by himself... the last time we saw that being effectively done was zidane, '06... that does put him in da same bracket as many of the greats... but he needs to mature... he has growth potential, still... thats his real cutting edge.... or otherwise, y would s.a.f. lament over losing him to madrid?
Por  arionweb
10.09.2009 13:20
Well to put ronaldo at this stage in the bracket of the greats is utterly rubbish...Football is a team game...remember what cruyff was for Ajax or giggs for united...A player should stand up to the task of grabbing a win from the hands of defeat...Had ronaldo killed barca(who were absolutely flawless) in CL then I would have said he can be compared to the greats...Pele single handedly made brazil a world class team, but the best thing about him was that he played for the team/country...same with maradona...but yes messi comes much closer to the greats in this regard although theres still plenty of time left for adjudgement..
Por  sam_flame
10.09.2009 17:50
dude, arun, stop hating ronaldo for leaving... hes not my favourite player(rooney is), and i regret the fact that he left...but we are a poorer team without him and that is the truth... we might surpass our levels once the other players(nani, anderson, gibson) stand up and start performing consistently. and he was bad just one game... against barca...nd look what happened, united played like shit. he could carry our team effortlessly. im not saying football is a one man game. a brazil without pele or an argentina without maradona can still win games, but you'd agree that they would be a poorer team overall... but there are certain players that pull the strings in a team, and ronnie is one of dem... his greatness lies in the fact that he can still improve(almost like an usain bolt). and i believe he will make it among the best of all times
Por  CCCPPlus
10.09.2009 21:48
lets not forget that Ronaldo-less MU beat Arsenal at home too. regarding Argentina without Maradona: lets really consider Argentina before and after. last time they sparked before 2006, Maradona drugged himself to fitness (1994), yet there were Batigol, Crespo, Lopez, Ayala, Samuel, Sorin, Zanetti, Veron, Riquelme etc between 94 and 06. in 86, Valdano and Ruggeri are not exactly Crespo and Ayala. Buruchaga was like England's Beardsley, not big names in 86 - but 'village' heroes. Maradona had played with 10 'villagers' - which i would not happily attribute Brazilians, Italians or French players of the time. Tigana, Fernandez, Giresse, or Stopyra, never mind Platini, are far from Beardsley-kind. i remember them being as flamboyant as Socrates, Junior, Josimar, Rummenige, Magath... it was like Zidane being born Greek winning them 2004 ---> which pretty much tells you abt 2004 :)))
Por  vlatko123
15.09.2009 11:12
non
Por  markhall
22.10.2009 05:48
ronaldos not gonna be remembered as an all time great in the same league as pele,maradonna or even cruyff,platini,van basten,gullit these players all have one thing in common?they played in the best INTERNATIONAL teams of their generation and shone over the rest in that team?thats where greatness is achieved?I don't think portugal and ronaldo will reach them heights?he's currently comparable with great players like george best and others who didn't get to play in the best international teams,portugal also had eusabio and he's often forgotten when talking about great players for the same reason?
Por  markhall
22.10.2009 05:54
OMG SORRY ABOUT THE MULTI POST it wouldn't send and when i refreshed it sent them all oops
Por  CCCPPlus
22.10.2009 06:35
thanks for the comment, Mark. Yyou made me blush with the 90+ comments, there :))
22.10.2009 14:12
Damn dude you carash my Dashboard page-lol-He is about as Close as i am to the Moon as He is To PELE-Dude never won a World Cup at 17 and i can't remember him in Escape To Victory-lol
Ao clicar em "Adicionar Comentário ", você está declarando que este post não violam os Termos de Uso do Footbo. Adicionar Comentário