Are Denilson & Diaby good enough for Arsenal?
Por 360footbal...

In my last post, I had a pop at Denilson and Diaby.

Michael took issue with some of what I said and wrote in to say:

'If you expect Denilson to be a playmaker (especially from DM) then you're right, hes not good enough. What he does effectively is keep the ball moving to the playmakers and when he does get a clear sight at goal he can hit them as we've seen. He is a short pass specialist that keeps the ball moving.

'He is very accurate bc he doesn't take chances and he does this game after game, and hes also underrated defensively.

'Regarding Diaby, I know the exact play you are referring to and Walcott was wrong, he ran too early and Spurs were playing too deep for a realistic ball to be played, Diaby was right in that case, Theo should have realized this and checked back like Diaby mentioned. I agree he dwells on the ball far too much and agree that he needs to be more positive, but that case you pointed out was not one of his fault entirely (In the barca game, same circumstance, YES it was his fault). The sky i sthe limit for Diaby if he can start making better decisions, funny how we said that about Eboue and he hasn't gotten any better :(

'I will say Rosicky and Eboue need to leave, In Rosicky's case I wouldnt mind giving him until Christmas to see what he can do, but Eboue continually shows he can't make the right decision when we need him to.'

My reply: On Denilson, I have to admit he's done better than I predicted. He does a job. But I preferred Flamini in his position. If you check his stats, you'll see Denilson covers a lot less ground than Flamini used to for Arsenal. So Denilson's not even a good enough 'water carrier' in my book because to use some other Arsenal fans' words: 'He's too lazy!'

On Diaby, I maintain he should have knocked the ball into the space Theo was running into. You don't always have to play to feet. Indeed, a good midfielder would realise the best pass for Theo is one he can run onto. The service Theo gets from the Arsenal midfield is generally appalling. They play him the wrong sort of pass. Diaby just wants everyone to play his way. But Diaby's way is largely ineffective. Diaby reminds me Alex Hleb, who used to dribble in circles and rarely shoot. Diaby has some ability but he gets caught on the ball too much, so I think he'll end up as another Hleb.

4  Comentários
15.04.2010 18:31
flamini and denilson play completely different styles, flamini was the engine of our midfield - closing down dive into tackles, work rate to defend and attack, remember we played with two cm then, denilson only dives into tackles he knows how to win, hes more of an interceptor and in this aspect he reads the game better than flamini. but flamini has his work rate and this is where he is better than denilson. all im saying is if denilson got flaminis 'engine' ie work rate close down...he would be a different animal. i always notice now opposition teams target denilson, but if he was tenacious he would be taken seriously. regarding diaby, all i can say is if he wants to become a better player he needs to learn how to play box-tobox. sort out his tackling..then learn some leadership skills so he can boss that midfield. walcott needs to work on technique, once he learns that hell be able to dribble and in the final third he would be able to do something. people may knock me for this but he should seriously start watching Thierry Henry videos. especially in the final third, if he didnt score hed make a assist. exactly what walcott needs to do - he has the ability but right now he plays like a headless chicken most times. all walcott does is abuse his pace...and thats all he has right now.
15.04.2010 19:50
Rosicky had a bad second half yesterday, but in the first one he was the only one who seemed to care. I don´t know why everyone blames him for everything lately. He made a great move dribbling past three players but he finished it wrong, and everyone just remembered the awful finishing. At least he tried to shoot, he was the only one who did so untill Van Persie came in.He was also great against Birmingham and Wolves (MOTM). He was bad against Barca, but he wasnt fit for that match.
15.04.2010 20:55
NO NO NO
16.04.2010 12:28
To Only1Great: I hear what you're saying about Denilson's style being different to Flamini. Denilson's very languid, which is all well and good if you're playmaker, but he's not! Flamini was Cesc's minder and I don't think anyone has adequately replaced him. Even Song is lazy compared to Flamini! But I must admit, Song reads the game well so has fitted into a 5-man midfield. The point is, Flamini covered so much ground we only needed 4 in midfield with him in the team! I agree Theo needs to work on his technique and should study Thierry videos, but then it won't be much use if Wenger doesn't learn to deploy him properly. The difference is Thierry was arrogant enough thankfully to play the way he wanted, whereas modest Theo listens too much to instructions from the bench and from clueless team-mates like Diaby! To Hernan Busso: I've had a go at Rosicky earlier this season, but I thought he did well against Spurs, so I'm hoping he'll stay at the club.
Ao clicar em "Adicionar Comentário ", você está declarando que este post não violam os Termos de Uso do Footbo. Adicionar Comentário